Notes |
- BeCAUSe her mother is named Judith, some have placed Catherine Elizabeth VEINOT 1790 as d/o Peter James and Anna Judith (DAUPHINEE) VEINOT. However, it can be shown that the wife of John VEINOT appears as both Catherine Margaret and Judith Margaret in multiple places. And from John VEINOT's LWT, it is clear that both Catherine Elizabeth 1788 and Catherine Elizabeth 1790 are their daughters. So the question then becomes--which Catherine Elizabeth married which husband?
In his LWT, John lists both his sons and his daughters in order of birth. Moreover, the two successive Catherine Elizabeth's are listed as "Catherine Elizabeth" and simply "Catherine", and it seems highly unlikely that both would have been addressed, at least within the family, by the same name. Now at marriage, the wife of Henry SHUBLEY is listed as "Elizabeth", while the wife of John Peter LOWE is listed as "Catherine".
Also, as Brenda Maruca points out, John VEINOT's LWT leaves 5 pounds to each daughter but only Catherine, Mary Elizabeth, and Ann Margaret are to receive a cow, calf, spinning wheel, and feather bed, which would indicate that Catherine Elizabeth is already married.
Therefore, in this genealogy, Catherine Elizabeth 1788 is assigned to Henry SHUBLEY and Catherine Elizabeth 1790 to John Peter LOWE.
|